Security ratings are scores produced by external providers from internet-observable data about an organisation, such as exposed services, certificate and email configuration and malware signals, without the organisation's participation.
What Security ratings means
Ratings are generated from the outside, so they can cover many vendors at low effort and update often. They are useful as a monitoring signal, for example when a vendor's exposed services change suddenly. They also need no input from the vendor.
They have limits. They see only the external attack surface, may attribute assets to the wrong organisation, and say nothing about internal controls, contracts, data handling or resilience. A vendor with a strong score may still lack the clauses or controls your service needs.
Use ratings as one input among several. Investigate significant changes, ask the vendor about specific issues, and base the decision on evidence about the service you buy. Record why a change in rating did or did not lead to a re-review.
What to check in vendor documents
- The specific issues behind a low or falling score, not only the number.
- Whether the flagged assets actually belong to the vendor and to your service.
- The vendor's response and remediation timeline for real issues.
- How the rating fits with the evidence from reports and contracts.
Related terms
- Continuous vendor monitoringContinuous vendor monitoring is the ongoing tracking of a vendor's risk between formal assessments, using triggers such as new reports, incidents, contract or sub-processor changes, financial events and external signals, so reviews happen when risk changes.
- Evidence-based assessmentAn evidence-based assessment is a vendor review in which every conclusion is tied to a specific source, such as a clause, page or test result in the vendor's documents, rather than to unverified questionnaire answers or reviewer judgement alone.
- Penetration test reportA penetration test report is the written result of an authorised simulated attack on a system, documenting the scope, method, findings with severity and recommendations. Vendors usually share a summary or a letter from the tester rather than the full report.
- Vendor due diligenceVendor due diligence is the assessment an organisation carries out before contracting with a vendor, and again at renewal, to confirm the vendor can deliver the service safely and meet the legal, security, financial and operational requirements that apply.
Sources
- NIST CSWP 29, The NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF) 2.0doi.org/10.6028/NIST.CSWP.29
Summarised for practitioners, not legal advice. Check the source text for your own obligations.