A vendor questionnaire is a structured set of questions sent to a vendor about its security, privacy, resilience and compliance practices, used to gather information for a risk assessment, often alongside or instead of documents.
What Vendor questionnaire means
Questionnaires can be standard, such as the SIG or the CSA CAIQ, or written in-house. They scale easily and cover areas no report addresses, such as the vendor's use of AI or how it manages its own suppliers. They also give a consistent baseline.
Their weakness is that answers are self-reported. A yes to 'do you encrypt data at rest' says nothing about scope or operation. Treat answers as claims to verify against documents: a SOC 2 test result, an ISO/IEC 27001 Statement of Applicability or a clause in the DPA.
Ask only what the tier needs, accept a standard questionnaire the vendor has already completed where it covers your needs, and ask for the document that supports each important answer. Record which answers were verified, and against which document, so the next review can start from them.
What to check in vendor documents
- Answers that conflict with the vendor's reports, certificates or contract.
- Not applicable answers on controls that clearly apply to the service.
- Answers without evidence on the questions that matter most for the tier.
- Who completed the questionnaire and when.
In ProcureCortex
ProcureCortex starts from the documents a vendor sends rather than from questionnaire answers, and each finding cites the excerpt and page it rests on.
How an assessment worksRelated terms
- SIG questionnaire (SIG)The SIG questionnaire is the Standardized Information Gathering questionnaire published by Shared Assessments: a standard set of third-party risk questions that a vendor can complete once and share with many customers, available in a shorter SIG Lite and a fuller SIG Core.
- CSA STAR and CAIQ (CAIQ)CSA STAR is the Cloud Security Alliance's assurance programme for cloud services, and the CAIQ is its standard questionnaire. Providers publish CAIQ self-assessments or third-party audit results, based on the Cloud Controls Matrix, in the public STAR Registry.
- Evidence-based assessmentAn evidence-based assessment is a vendor review in which every conclusion is tied to a specific source, such as a clause, page or test result in the vendor's documents, rather than to unverified questionnaire answers or reviewer judgement alone.
- Vendor due diligenceVendor due diligence is the assessment an organisation carries out before contracting with a vendor, and again at renewal, to confirm the vendor can deliver the service safely and meet the legal, security, financial and operational requirements that apply.
- Vendor tieringVendor tiering is the practice of sorting vendors into risk tiers, based on factors such as the data they handle, the functions they support and how hard they are to replace, so that review depth, evidence and monitoring match the risk.
Sources
- Interagency Guidance on Third-Party Relationships: Risk Management, 88 FR 37920 (June 2023)www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2023-06-09/html/2023-12340.htm
- Cloud Security Alliance, STAR programme and registrycloudsecurityalliance.org/star
Summarised for practitioners, not legal advice. Check the source text for your own obligations.