The carve-out and inclusive methods are the two ways a SOC report can treat a vendor's subservice organisations. The carve-out method excludes their controls from the examination; the inclusive method describes and tests them within the report.
What Carve-out vs inclusive method means
A subservice organisation is a provider that the service organisation uses to perform part of its service, such as a cloud hosting provider or data centre. Under the inclusive method, the system description includes the subservice organisation's relevant controls and the auditor tests them, which needs that provider's cooperation.
Under the carve-out method, which vendors commonly use for large cloud providers, the subservice organisation's controls are excluded. The report names the provider, describes the services it performs and lists the complementary subservice organisation controls the vendor assumes it operates. The vendor should monitor that provider, often by reviewing its own SOC report.
For a reviewer, carve-out means part of the control environment was not tested in the report you are reading. You need the subservice organisation's own assurance report, or evidence that the vendor reviews it, before you rely on the whole service.
What to check in vendor documents
- Which subservice organisations are named, and which method applies to each.
- The complementary subservice organisation controls listed for carved-out providers.
- The vendor's control for monitoring its subservice organisations, and its test result.
- Whether carved-out providers also appear on the DPA sub-processor list.
- The subservice organisation's own SOC report for services you depend on.
Related terms
- SOC 2 report (SOC 2)A SOC 2 report is an independent CPA firm's attestation report, under AICPA standards, on a service organisation's system and its controls relevant to security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality or privacy, measured against the AICPA Trust Services Criteria.
- Fourth-party riskFourth-party risk is the risk that comes from the providers your vendors rely on to deliver their service to you, such as cloud hosting, data centres, payment processors or AI model providers, with whom you usually have no contract.
- Complementary user entity controls (CUECs)Complementary user entity controls (CUECs) are controls that a SOC report assumes the customer operates. If the customer does not operate them, the vendor's controls may not meet their stated criteria or control objectives.
- Sub-processorA sub-processor is another processor engaged by a vendor to carry out specific processing of personal data on the controller's behalf. Under GDPR Article 28(2) and 28(4), it needs the controller's authorisation and must be bound by the same data protection obligations.
Sources
- AICPA, SOC 2: SOC for Service Organizations, Trust Services Criteriawww.aicpa-cima.com/topic/audit-assurance/audit-and-assurance-greater-than-soc-2
Summarised for practitioners, not legal advice. Check the source text for your own obligations.