Platform OverviewOne evidence trail, from intake to Jira.See how it fits together
See it on your documentsA 30-minute call. Bring a vendor you are reviewing now.Book a demo
Third-party risk conceptsPublished Updated

Compensating control

Definition

A compensating control is an alternative control that meets the intent of a requirement when the primary control cannot be implemented, giving a similar level of protection against the same risk.

What Compensating control means

PCI DSS formalises the idea in Appendix B. An entity with a legitimate and documented technical or business constraint can use a compensating control, provided it meets the intent and rigour of the original requirement, provides a similar level of defence, goes above and beyond other PCI DSS requirements, and is documented and validated.

In vendor review, compensating controls work in two directions. A vendor may cite one for a missing control, which you need evidence for. You may also put one in place yourself, such as extra monitoring or restricted data sharing, to accept a vendor with a known gap.

A compensating control is credible only if it addresses the same risk and is tested. Record which finding it compensates for and how you will know it works. A vendor's statement that it has a compensating control is a claim, not evidence, until you have seen how it works.

What to check in vendor documents

  • The requirement that is not met, and why.
  • The alternative control, and how it addresses the same risk.
  • Evidence that the alternative control operates, such as test results.
  • PCI DSS AOC entries for requirements met with a compensating control worksheet.

Related terms

Sources

  1. PCI Security Standards Council, document library (PCI DSS v4.0.1 and AOC templates)www.pcisecuritystandards.org/document_library
  2. NIST CSRC glossary, compensating controlscsrc.nist.gov/glossary/term/compensating_controls

Summarised for practitioners, not legal advice. Check the source text for your own obligations.

Compensating control: questions

Short, direct answers.

No. A compensating control reduces the risk by other means. Risk acceptance leaves the risk as it is and records the decision.

See it on your own vendor documents.

Open a demo workspace with a sample vendor, its documents and its findings. Or bring your own vendor to a 30-minute call.

Procurement, compliance, security and auditOne workspace, one record of every decision