A compensating control is an alternative control that meets the intent of a requirement when the primary control cannot be implemented, giving a similar level of protection against the same risk.
What Compensating control means
PCI DSS formalises the idea in Appendix B. An entity with a legitimate and documented technical or business constraint can use a compensating control, provided it meets the intent and rigour of the original requirement, provides a similar level of defence, goes above and beyond other PCI DSS requirements, and is documented and validated.
In vendor review, compensating controls work in two directions. A vendor may cite one for a missing control, which you need evidence for. You may also put one in place yourself, such as extra monitoring or restricted data sharing, to accept a vendor with a known gap.
A compensating control is credible only if it addresses the same risk and is tested. Record which finding it compensates for and how you will know it works. A vendor's statement that it has a compensating control is a claim, not evidence, until you have seen how it works.
What to check in vendor documents
- The requirement that is not met, and why.
- The alternative control, and how it addresses the same risk.
- Evidence that the alternative control operates, such as test results.
- PCI DSS AOC entries for requirements met with a compensating control worksheet.
Related terms
- Risk acceptanceRisk acceptance is a documented decision by an authorised person to proceed with a known risk without further treatment, recording the risk, the reason, any conditions and when the decision will be reviewed.
- Residual riskResidual risk is the risk that remains after controls, contract terms and other treatments have been applied. In vendor review, it is the risk the organisation actually accepts when it approves the vendor.
- PCI DSS Attestation of Compliance (AOC)A PCI DSS Attestation of Compliance (AOC) is the PCI Security Standards Council form that declares an entity's compliance status with the Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard, following either a Report on Compliance or a self-assessment questionnaire.
- Complementary user entity controls (CUECs)Complementary user entity controls (CUECs) are controls that a SOC report assumes the customer operates. If the customer does not operate them, the vendor's controls may not meet their stated criteria or control objectives.
Sources
- PCI Security Standards Council, document library (PCI DSS v4.0.1 and AOC templates)www.pcisecuritystandards.org/document_library
- NIST CSRC glossary, compensating controlscsrc.nist.gov/glossary/term/compensating_controls
Summarised for practitioners, not legal advice. Check the source text for your own obligations.